CraftPack Global TeamOct 15, 2026

EU 10/2011 vs. US FDA: Food Contact Packaging Compliance

Food contact packaging compliance laboratory testing with transparent flexible barrier pouches and chemical simulant glass beakers

On this page

For international food brands, multinational contract packagers, and flexible packaging converters distributing across transatlantic markets, navigating food contact material (FCM) legislation is a critical regulatory milestone. Packaging that comes into direct contact with food must be chemically inert: it must not transfer constituent chemicals to food in quantities that endanger human health, alter food composition, or impair organoleptic sensory qualities.

However, the regulatory architectures of the European Union (EU) and the United States (US FDA) are fundamentally distinct. While the EU operates under the harmonized, chemistry-centric Commission Regulation (EU) No 10/2011 and Framework Regulation (EC) 1935/2004, the US FDA regulates packaging under the Code of Federal Regulations (21 CFR Parts 174–178) and the Food Contact Notification (FCN) program.

Assuming that an FDA-cleared pouch automatically complies with EU directives—or vice versa—is a frequent cause of customs border rejections, product recalls, and severe legal liabilities.

This technical guide provides a comparative engineering evaluation of EU 10/2011 vs. US FDA 21 CFR Food Contact Compliance, analyzing Overall Migration Limits (OML), Specific Migration Limits (SML), food simulant selection protocols, and Declaration of Compliance (DoC) documentation.


1. Technical Matrix: EU 10/2011 vs. US FDA 21 CFR Comparison

Regulatory Parameter European Union: Regulation (EU) 10/2011 United States: FDA 21 CFR Parts 174–178
Governing Framework Regulation (EC) No 1935/2004 + (EU) 10/2011 Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (FD&C Act)
Positive Substance List Union List of Authorized Substances (Annex I) 21 CFR Indirect Food Additives + Active FCN Database
Overall Migration Limit (OML) Strictly Mandated: $10\text{ mg/dm}^2$ or $60\text{ mg/kg}$ No universal OML; regulated per specific polymer extraction
Specific Migration Limit (SML) Enforced for hundreds of individual monomers/additives Regulated via daily intake (EDI) and toxicological thresholds
Non-Intentionally Added Substances (NIAS) Mandatory risk assessment under Article 19 Evaluated during pre-market clearance / general safety
Standard Food Simulants Simulants A, B, C, D1, D2, and E (Polytenax) Food Types I through IX (Water, Heptane, 8%–50% Alcohol)
Worst-Case Testing Conditions Standardized Time/Temp Protocols (OM1 to OM7) Prescribed extraction test conditions per specific polymer rule
Declaration of Compliance (DoC) Legally Mandatory across all supply chain stages Voluntary unless requested by buyer; LOA (Letter of Assurance)
Good Manufacturing Practice (GMP) Regulation (EC) No 2023/2006 (Strictly Audited) 21 CFR 174.5 General Provisions for Good Manufacturing Practice

To inspect our food-grade certified flexible packaging portfolio, explore our Stand-up Pouches Category and Food Service Bags Category.


2. Chemical Migration Framework: OML vs. SML in EU 10/2011

The European Union framework evaluates flexible packaging through two complementary analytical thresholds:

Chemical Migration Architecture under (EU) 10/2011:
┌────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│  Overall Migration Limit (OML)                         │
│  - Maximum allowed total inert chemical transfer       │
│  - Threshold: Strictly ≤ 10 mg/dm² (or 60 mg/kg food)  │ <── Measures general inertness
├────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│  Specific Migration Limit (SML)                        │
│  - Toxicological threshold for specific molecules      │
│  - Examples: Primary Aromatic Amines (PAA < 0.01 mg/kg)│ <── Protects consumer health
│              Caprolactam (Nylon monomer < 15 mg/kg)    │
│              Bisphenol A (BPA < 0.05 mg/kg; Banned)    │
└────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
  1. Overall Migration Limit (OML):

    • Meant to ensure that the packaging material is toxicologically inert and does not alter food composition.
    • Tested by exposing the finished packaging film to standardized chemical food simulants under accelerated time-temperature conditions (e.g., OM2: 10 days at 40°C for long-term ambient storage; OM5: 2 hours at 100°C for hot-fill).
    • The total non-volatile residue leached into the simulant must not exceed $10\text{ mg per square decimeter}$ ($10\text{ mg/dm}^2$) of contact surface area.
  2. Specific Migration Limits (SML):

    • The EU Union List assigns toxicologically derived maximum concentrations for individual restricted monomers, plasticizers, and stabilizers.
    • For example, when using polyurethane lamination adhesives, converters must prove that unreacted isocyanate monomers do not migrate as Primary Aromatic Amines (PAA) above the detection threshold of $0.01\text{ mg/kg}$.

3. Food Simulants Comparison: EU vs. US FDA

Because testing migration with real food matrices (like curry sauce or olive oil) is chemically complex, both regulatory systems define standardized liquid chemical simulants:

Standard Food Simulant Cross-Reference:
Food Matrix Characterization           European Union Simulant ((EU) 10/2011)        US FDA Equivalent Simulant (21 CFR)
───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
Aqueous / Non-Acidic (pH > 4.5)        Simulant A (10% Ethanol v/v)                  Deionized Water
Acidic Foods (pH < 4.5, Citrus/Tomato) Simulant B (3% Acetic Acid w/v)               3% Acetic Acid
Alcoholic Foods (Up to 20% Alcohol)    Simulant C (20% Ethanol v/v)                  8% or 50% Ethanol (by volume)
High-Alcohol / Dairy Emulsions         Simulant D1 (50% Ethanol v/v)                 50% Ethanol
Fatty Foods (Oils, Meats, Butter)      Simulant D2 (Vegetable Oil - Olive Oil)       Food-Grade Heptane / Corn Oil
Dry Powder Foods (Flour, Sugar)        Simulant E (Poly(2,6-diphenyl-p-phenylene))    None (Exempt / Low Migration)
  • The Fatty Food Simulant Divergence: In the EU, Simulant D2 (rectified olive oil) is the mandatory standard for fatty foods, requiring complex chromatographic extraction. In contrast, the US FDA permits food-grade n-heptane as a rapid solvent extraction substitute, which represents a more aggressive solvent extraction than olive oil and requires specific temperature conversion factors.

4. The Declaration of Compliance (DoC) Audit Trail

Under Article 16 of Regulation (EU) 10/2011, every flexible packaging supplier in the supply chain—from resin manufacturer to masterbatch compounder, adhesive converter, and printer—must provide a written Declaration of Compliance (DoC):

Mandatory Components of an EU Declaration of Compliance (DoC):
1. Identity and address of business operator issuing the DoC.
2. Identity of the packaging materials (Resin grades, films, adhesives, inks).
3. Date of declaration and confirmation of compliance with (EC) 1935/2004 & (EC) 2023/2006.
4. Information on substances subject to SML restrictions (Identity and SML values).
5. Information on Dual-Use Food Additives (Preservatives/antioxidants also regulated in food).
6. Specifications on the intended use of the material:
   - Types of food permitted (Aqueous, acidic, alcoholic, fatty).
   - Time and temperature limits of contact and storage (e.g., Up to 121°C for 30 min retort).
   - Surface area to volume ratio used to establish compliance (Standard: 6 dm² per 1 kg food).
  • In contrast, the US FDA does not legally mandate a standardized DoC document; instead, buyers typically request a Letter of Assurance (LOA) or Letter of Guarantee (LOG) citing specific 21 CFR clearances (e.g., 21 CFR 177.1520 for olefin polymers).

5. Global Compliance Checklist for Packaging Procurement

              Where will your packaged food product be distributed and sold?
                                     │
                     ┌───────────────┴───────────────┐
          European Union & UK Markets                   United States & North America
                     │                               │
        Does your packaging converter have      Are all resin components, colorants,
         a comprehensive (EU) 10/2011 DoC?       and adhesives cleared under 21 CFR?
                     │                               │
        ┌────────────┴────────────┐             ┌────┴──────────────────────────┐
       YES                        NO            │ Deploy FDA 21 CFR Portfolio:  │
        │                          │            │ - 21 CFR 177.1520 (Polyolefins│
  Full EU Compliance Established:  │            │ - 21 CFR 175.105 (Adhesives)  │
  - Migration tests under OML      │            │ - Effective FCN notifications │
  - SML thresholds verified        │            │ - Good Manufacturing Practice │
  - NIAS risk assessment logged    │            └───────────────────────────────┘
  - CEPI recyclability confirmed   │
  - Valid for European retail      └──────────> Immediate Audit Required:
                                                Commission accredited lab test
                                                for OML and SML migration

CraftPack Global manufactures all food-grade packaging within certified ISO 9001 and BRCGS-compliant facilities, providing complete third-party laboratory migration reports, FDA Letters of Guarantee, and European Declarations of Compliance.

Consult our regulatory compliance specialists to review your packaging specifications via our Food Packaging Division.